close
close
Alachua County Commission seats are decided by single-member districts

For the first time in Alachua County history, all voters will have no say in who is elected to the County Commission this year.

A single-district referendum, approved in November 2022 with approximately 51.5% of the vote, means that only voters residing in a particular district will cast ballots to elect their commissioner. All five commissioners were previously elected at the county level.

This year, there are only two seats up for grabs on the County Commission, both in the southwest corner of the county. Democratic incumbent Anna Prizzia will face Republican challenger Jenn Garrett in November, while District 1 incumbent Mary Alford will face Dejeon Cain in the Aug. 20 Democratic primary to determine who will face Lizabeth Ann Doebler in November. District 5 Commissioner Charles “Chuck” Chestnut is running unopposed.

“While I personally support at-large voting, I think the more important issue is allowing Alachua County residents to vote at-large with facts instead of the misinformation that was mailed to residents and funded by dark money prior to the last election,” Alford wrote in an email to The Sun. “Residents I have spoken to have overwhelmingly supported putting the issue back on the ballot. Many also support at-large voting and believe the commissioners represent their districts well while working for the good of the entire county. But we’ll see in November!”

Dejeon Cain, Alford’s primary opponent, said he understands both sides of the issue.

“I can see the pros and cons of how voters feel about the single-member district and at-large voting for county commission,” said Cain, who has served on several government advisory boards and committees. “I’ll be comfortable with whatever the voters decide. I’m right there with the voters.”

Single-member districts have been a contentious issue in the county since the last election cycle, when many Republican groups, including Commissioner Ken Cornell, accused voters of using misleading quotes and mailers to confuse voters on the issue. At the time, Cornell suggested that single-member district advocates were breaking campaign laws to get the measure implemented.

Supporters of single-member districts spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on advertising, while county officials were prohibited by law from producing any content addressing the referendum.

Voters in November will once again be able to decide whether to keep or reject the idea of ​​single-member districts in the future after the commission voted earlier this year to put the issue back on the ballot.

“A lot of my district members are not happy with the fact that during this election they will not have a say, they will not be able to vote for any of the three seats,” Cornell said in May. “I think it’s completely appropriate for me to represent the people of my district, listen to them and put this back on the ballot.”

Supporters of single-member districts say they allow more moderate and conservative voices to be elected to the County Commission, which has historically been dominated by Democratic leaders. Opponents, however, say single-member districts are undemocratic, since all members make decisions on behalf of all county residents.